Western feminism, analyzing and conceptualizing conflict, thesis for the degree of master of science, international studies, central connecticut state university, may 2003, chapter nine conclusion, p 7082. As it grew to encompass those women who were not white and middle class it was caught in the trap that ensnares most social movements. In other words, islamic feminism is a feminist discourse and practice articulated within an islamic paradigm badran 2009, 242. Pdf islam, muslim feminism and womens rights in malaysia. Nor is it evident that those who first used it were aware of the explosive impact that the juxtaposition of these two words was to have. A very short introduction alina isac alak university of bucharest, romania alina. Perhaps no other social movement has wrought such profound changes in social morals and attitudes. Feminism distinguished from other womens movements women have been oppressed ever since the invention of human sin, and for nearly as long they have been engaged in the attempt to free themselves from oppression. In my opinion, there is no ideology more irreconcilable with feminism than islam. The attempts made to end the injustices done to women, particularly when these injustices are institutionalized, may be called womens movements. The most confusing thing for the nonmuslims particularly in the western world is the position of women in islam. Islam doesnt mandate the superiority of one sex over the other, but strives to achieve balance between the sexes. Muslim women vary in race, social class, culture, and as people, and may range considerably from those following islam in a typically conservative way to women with a more.
She writes that the long domination of patriarchy has led to a lack of awareness about feminism. Islamic feminism the term islamic feminism was first used in the 1990s. It is a kneejerk response that shows at best ignorance and. Between islam and feminism article pdf available in journal of feminist studies in religion 322. Dilemmas of islamic and secular feminists and feminisms. The term islamic feminism began to surface in the 1990s in various global locations. The reality and future of islamic feminism afghanistan al. Thats like saying you can be a ku klux klan member and an antifascist. It examines womens and mens social roles, experiences, interests, chores, and feminist politics in a variety of fields, such as anthropology and sociology, communication, media studies, psychoanalysis, home economics, literature. They are not foils with which to bash islam or through which sympathetic westerners can congratulate themselves on their cultural superiority. Islamic feminism insists on full equality of women and men across the publicprivate spectrum secular feminists historically accepted the idea of equality in the public sphere and the notion of complementarianism in the private sphere.
Islamic feminism in postmodern egypt reclaiming women. Dec 22, 20 a s a person who writes about womens issues, i am constantly being told that islam is the greatest threat to gender equality in this or any other country mostly by white men, who always know. Oct 02, 2017 feminism was supposed to be about gender equality, not about promoting and pushing the rights of women above and beyond those of men. Feminism among muslim women, like feminism among nonmuslim women, is hugely varied and. The basic idea behind the feminism is that womens position in society is unequal to. Iranian scholar ziba mirhosseini exposed the rise and use of the term islamic feminism by some women, as well as men, writing in the teheran womens journal. Feminism, she goes on, is mistakenly identified in iran as. No matter how much some western muslim women attempt to hijack the creed of feminism to suit their interests blurring the distinction between their islamic values a. Thats just a small sample of the responses i got on twitter last week when i said i was taking part in a panel discussion about islam and feminism. These laws were especially discriminatory of married women. Feminist advocates or supports the rights and equality of. A brief history of feminism islam versus feminism al. According to western perspective feminism is a history of struggles for womens rights and freedoms and emphasizes that religion is one of the chief enemies of its progress. Islamic feminism and feminist theory by catherine williams.
Quotes tagged as islamicfeminism showing 12 of 2 if you ask muslim women why they cover up, ninetynine percent of them will say its to avoid arousing men. Islamic feminism is defined by islamic scholars as being more radical than secular feminism and as being anchored within the discourse of islam with the quran as its central text. In their conception a muslim woman is a secluded and passive subject, who neither has any. If you are talking about the original feminism that consisted right for a woman to own her stuff when she is married right to vote right to work against wife beating then its ok, because islam allows all these things but modern day femin. Dilemmas of islamic and secular feminists and feminisms1 by huma ahmedghosh2 abstract this paper explores ways in which a multifaceted understanding of islamic feminism can contribute to productive dialogue about the future of muslim women in both islamic and secular states. Thewhywas the beginning of an analysis of patriarchythat is, the power men had accorded themselves. Islamic feminism in egypt is often associated with the flow of islamism. Feminism in malaysia a historical and present perspective of womens struggles in malaysia. This includes seeking to establish equal opportunities for women in educationand employment. Why feminism is awol on islam online political commentary.
Volume 11, issue 1 2009 gender and islam in asia bridgewater. It was not about creating more divide between the sexes. The islamic traditionlike other major religious traditionsdoes not consist of, or derive from, a single source. I n a shift away from normative scholarship on the status or role of women in. Feminism is a powerful movement, but it has its limits. A combination of islam and feminism has been advocated as a feminist discourse and practice. Badran carefully balances attention to major thinkers and writers with her grasp of the issues feminists faced and addressed, along with the opponents and. Abstract the discussion in the current debate primarily explores the major areas in islamic discourses that are criticized by scholars and critics. The general perception towards the idea of islamic feminism is that islam is a repressive patriarchal religion, and thus, can never coexist with feminism, since. Legal and literary perspectives is the title of saudi scholar mai yamanis 1996 book comprising the essays of a substantial number of women scholars who are articulating an emerging islamic feminism. Veil and the male elite a feminist interpretation of womens rights in islam by, fatima mernissi. It fragmented, became exclusive rather than inclusive. Jul, 2017 an islamic sarsour style of feminism has to be shariacompliant in the if you cant beat em, join em mode. Islamic feminism is a relatively recent current of thought being developed by a transnational network of activists in widely contrasting sociopolitical contexts.
Islamic feminism is defined by islamic scholars as being more radical than secular feminism, and as being anchored within the discourse of islam with the quran as its central text. To some extend muslim feminists are reluctant to even use the term feminism, as feminism in muslim context often is regarded as an extensive part of. Sep 07, 2016 if you are talking about the original feminism that consisted right for a woman to own her stuff when she is married right to vote right to work against wife beating then its ok, because islam allows all these things but modern day femin. It is in this context that questions about the possibility and desirability of islamic feminism arise. Feminism, fehm uh nihz uhm,3 is the belief that women should have economic political and social equality with men. Mar 08, 2018 islamic feminism is a relatively recent current of thought being developed by a transnational network of activists in widely contrasting sociopolitical contexts. Introduction feminism has radically altered western culture in the latter half of the twentieth century. Islam, gender, women group of the american academy of religion. It aims to understand the nature of gender inequality. When speaking of islamic feminism, one must take into account the meaning of the two words that make up this term. Feminists in the west may fiddle while muslim women are burning, but in the muslim world itself there is a burgeoning movement to address the miserable predicament of the second sexwithout simply adopting a philosophy whose higher cultural products include sex and the city, rosie odonnell, and the powersuited female executive. Feminism was supposed to be about gender equality, not about promoting and pushing the rights of women above and beyond those of men. Islamic feminism is a transnational movement that seeks to reinscribe questions of gender and womens rights into islamic thought and practice.
And if there is any reference or analysis to feminism, it is mixed with negative convictions sherkat 1993a. Compared to todays mainstream western feminism, islamic feminism is less discussed and less visible in feminist conversations. Feminism as a western movement originated in england during the 18th century and had as one of its main goals the eradication of legal disabilities imposed upon women by english common law. Archived pdf from the original on 21 december 2018. Sources of the tradition before engaging in any meaningful discussion of feminism in islam, it is useful to refer to the sources of the islamic tradition, since much confusion surrounds the use of the term islam. A s a person who writes about womens issues, i am constantly being told that islam is the greatest threat to gender equality in this or any other country mostly by white men, who always know. Contextualizing equality of gender in islam kamran shahid. Those who advocate that feminist projects be conducted within an islamic framework have clearly despaired of secular options for change without considering how have elaborated lilas argument against the possibility of the coexistence of islam and feminism because it explains the anxiety many. Religion, inevitably, was to play a major role in this enterprise.
Islamic feminism and feminist theory abstract western feminist theory has developed significantly from its early roots in the suffrage movement. D candidate at the university of texas at austin, gave a talk feb. Sexual revolution and liberation meant that sexual relations should be freed of the constraints associated with traditional christian virtue. For feminism to accomplish its goal, major social, economic, political and cultural changes in our society must be made. Such beneficent regulation is essential for peace, comfort, happiness, continuation of the species and progress. Feminism is a social movement whose goal is to do away with the subjugation of women in every way. Secular and religious convergences by margot badran. Feminism is a secular ideology and islam today rests on fundamentalist foundations. As a school of thought, it is said to refer to moroccan sociologist fatema mernissi and. The term feminism also refers to a political movement that works to gain such equality. The future of islamic feminism may see stronger social institutions and resources that support women and an end to the sugarcoating and apologetics, but most importantly, it may see a renaissance. The term islamic feminism became popular in the 1990s, defining an emerging feminist paradigm by scholars including ziba mirhosseini, mai yamani, nilufer gole and shamima shaikh.
The debate over womens rights and islam is often politicized and riddled with stereotypes. Muslim women are not all victims, renegades or standardbearers for religious or cultural authenticity. New age islam by bina shah february 20, 2017 ive been reading about australian youth activist yassmin abdelmagied we appeared on an australian show once together and her words to jacqui lambie on an australian broadcasting corporation abc television show that islam is to her the most feminist religion. An islamic sarsour style of feminism has to be shariacompliant in the if you cant beat em, join em mode. As such, it challenges both the more westerncentric conceptions. Talk explores role of islamic feminism the ithacan. Woman in islam in the divine scheme of regulation of the relationship between men and women, islam has assigned a position of dignity and honour to woman.
Such women have a high degree of tolerance for domestic violence and oppression of. The first part is devoted to feminism in egypt, and the second traces the spread of feminism in the broader muslim world. Islam vs feminism contemporary topics of islamic thought. Feminism ziba mirhosseini abstract islamic feminism has gained currency since the 1990s and has become the label for a new brand of feminist scholarship and activism that is associated with islam. Feminism ids bulletin volume 42 number 1 january 2011 beyond islam vs. In recent times, islamic feminism has emerged as a challenge to patriarchy in muslim societies. What constitutes an islamic feminism, and where is it headed. Contemporary islamic feminisms, already quite diverse, deconstruct preceding islamic interpretations, proposing more egalitarian rereadings and reconceptualizations. From the religious right to feminist theology katsuhiro kohara introduction christianity is a religion that has always had a deep involvement with issues relating to women and religion. Given the varieties of islam and feminisms that exist, a fixed. Analyzing a conceptual conflict reference url share. The reality and future of islamic feminism afghanistan.
Islam, patriarchy, and feminism in the middle east margot badran the study of women in the middle east, now well into its second decade, has produced an impressive corpus of papers and periodical articles. Islamic feminism argues that women may be heads of state, leaders of congregational prayer, judges, and muftis. Feminist theory is the extension of feminism into theoretical, fictional, or philosophical discourse. It was women of the christian world who started to insist that women should have equal rights to men. The success of transnational religious and feminist movements throughout the globe is simultaneously endorsing the tension between essentialised notions of islam and the west and directing the move towards reinterpreting modernity and redefining. But just as modern sociopolitical models in the muslim world after the colonial period began, in the 20th century, to shift from western models of society and government to islamic models, feminism in the muslim world began to take on islamic forms rather than imitating. Thus began my lifelong love affair with islamic feminism.
1232 1064 423 234 492 1081 1329 289 239 601 1147 450 1222 1244 1178 416 856 859 734 185 706 1451 1483 1106 359 847 1454 733 793